Contact Us





Anti-Spam Question:
 

Court Rules that a Defense Expert Cannot Review MRI Films for the First Time at Trial

By Attorney Michael B. Zerres on June 9, 2011

In a non-medical malpractice case, but on an issue that is certainly relevant to medical malpractice practioners, the Appellate Division in Ingrao v. Goncalves, A-1332-10T1, ruled that a defense expert could not examine MRI films for the first time in Court.

The case involved a damages only trial following a motor vehicle accident. Defendant’s examining defense expert, Francis DeLuca M.D. attempted to review MRI films taken of the patient’s lumbar spine for the first time in Court. Those films were available for review well before trial and Dr. DeLuca never requested copies to review when he examined the plaintiff, or, at any time thereafter.

The trial Court ruled that he could not review them for the very first time at trial in an attempt to bolster his opinions that the patient’s injuries were not from the motor vehicle accident in question. The Appellate Court agreed, finding that, “if it was important to defendants that Dr. DeLuca examine the MRI films to bolster his expert opinions, then defense counsel should have assured that the films were provided to Dr. DeLuca before trial.” Naturally, in such a situation, Dr. DeLuca would have had to have issued a report regarding his review of the MRI films prior to the discovery end date in order for such opinions to be admissible.

Related Articles:

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Chatham: (973) 635-5400     Jersey City: (201) 963-4711     Sea Girt: (732) 758-6333     North Bergen: (201) 861-7757

New Jersey Medical Malpractice Attorney Disclaimer: The New Jersey medical malpractice, accident, injury, serious accident, or other personal injury legal information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice, nor the formation of a lawyer or attorney client relationship. Any results set forth herein are based upon the facts of that particular case and do not represent a promise or guarantee. Please contact a New Jersey Personal Injury Attorney or Medical Malpractice Lawyer for a consultation on your particular medical malpractice matter. This web site is not intended to solicit clients for matters outside of the state of New Jersey.

© 2014 Super Lawyers®, Super Lawyers is a registered trademark of Thomson Reuters.

Copyright © 2012 Blume Goldfaden Berkowitz Donnelly Fried & Forte, Chatham, NJ - All rights reserved. Attorneys serving all New Jersey Counties and Communities.