Contact Us

Anti-Spam Question:

Appellate Court Affirms that Plaintiff May Read in Testimony of Unavailable Treating Physicians – Sheets V. Siegler (Decided March 27, 2015) (A-1836-11T4)

By Attorney Michael B. Zerres on March 16, 2016

In this dental malpractice case, the plaintiff experienced excruciating pain following a wisdom tooth extraction performed by the defendant dentist. She later developed numbness in her tongue and shooting pain from the back of her jaw, causing her difficulty speaking and swallowing. The patient, thereafter, underwent surgery to repair an apparent injury to her right lingual nerve. However, her difficulties remained, and she began receiving steroid injections to treat what was diagnosed as a neuroma of the right lingual nerve.

At trial, a jury returned a verdict against the defendant dentist in the amount of $2,300,035. The defendant appealed, arguing that trial judge improperly applied R. 4:16-1, whereby plaintiff’s counsel had been allowed to read portions of the treating doctors’ deposition testimony to the jury; it was claimed this procedure deprived defense counsel of the opportunity to cross examine these witnesses.

The Appellate Court disagreed with the defendant, on the grounds that R. 4:16-1(c) authorizes a party to read deposition testimony of a fact witness if the witness is unavailable, and the witness’ unavailability was not caused by the party seeking the admission of said testimony. In upholding the Trial Court’s decision, the Appellate Division held that the trial court properly characterized the doctors as fact witnesses, because they treated plaintiff for her injury and were not retained to opine as to whether the defendant deviated from the standard of care and/or support her damages claims. The Court further held that the doctors’ affidavits properly established their unavailability to testify and, therefore, plaintiff’s counsel was permitted to read the their testimony at trial in accordance with R. 4:16-1(c).

Related Articles:

Posted in: Medical Malpractice

Chatham: (973) 635-5400     Jersey City: (201) 963-4711     Sea Girt: (732) 758-6333     North Bergen: (201) 861-7757

New Jersey Medical Malpractice Attorney Disclaimer: The New Jersey medical malpractice, accident, injury, serious accident, or other personal injury legal information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice, nor the formation of a lawyer or attorney client relationship. Any results set forth herein are based upon the facts of that particular case and do not represent a promise or guarantee. Please contact a New Jersey Personal Injury Attorney or Medical Malpractice Lawyer for a consultation on your particular medical malpractice matter. This web site is not intended to solicit clients for matters outside of the state of New Jersey.

© 2018 Super Lawyers®, Super Lawyers is a registered trademark of Thomson Reuters.

Copyright © 2018 Blume Goldfaden Berkowitz Donnelly Fried & Forte, Chatham, NJ - All rights reserved. Attorneys serving all New Jersey Counties and Communities.